Guide rods for the 1911

[Bwana416]

Most built for defensive uses seem to have a full length guide rod. The Kimber SIS has a "military length" rod whatever that is. Functionally what difference is there? Kimber says the shorter rod enables easier field cleaning.:confused:

-Ray

[MOGC]

I wouldn't say "most built for defensive uses have a full length guide rod" as most top line custom guns actually do not. I dislike the full length rod, it is a pain in the rear to take the gun down. A "GI" plug and spring is just fine and has worked for a very long time and is easier to tear the gun down in a tool less crisis situation - whatever that might be.

[Phil T]

I've owned a 1911 of one brand and size or another since around 1966. I consider a full-length guide rods and an external extractors solutions in search of a problem.

[Bwana416]

I only asked because a legion of "experts" both in print and at ranges have stated in no uncertain terms that a combat 1911 should have a full length guide rod but I didn't see why. MAYBE for a comp gun but even then I am unsure.

-Ray

[Badger]

Bwana,

Yes, some pistols do have full length guide rods, but John Browning decided the "GI" rod was fine for his 1911. It has worked for 98 years so far.

Badger

[MOGC]

You'll find just as many if not more "experts" that hate the full length rods.